JCCC Digital Proctoring Comparison

This is a draft in progress while we are still collecting information:

  Respondus Lockdown Browser Respondus Lockdown + Respondus Monitor  YuJa Proctoring Option Zoom Live and Recording
Cost to Student Free, unlimited exams Free, unlimited exams Free, unlimited exams Free, unlimited exams
Access for Students All JCCC Courses All JCCC Courses All JCCC Courses All JCCC Courses
Accessibility ADA  VPAT

Respondus KB

 VPAT

Respondus KB

 VPAT Zoom Accessibility including VPAT
Assistive Technology

      
Supported OS and Browsers Windows/Mac/Chromebook

Lockdown Browser

 Windows/Mac/Chromebook

Lockdown Browser

 Windows/Mac Windows/Mac/Phone
Canvas Integration Yes Yes Yes Yes
Publisher Integration

 Pearson MyLabs

McGraw-Hill ALEKS

 Pearson MyLabs

McGraw-Hill ALEKS

 No Publisher Dependency No Publisher Dependency
Live proctoring No No No Yes
Automated proctoring No Yes No No
On-Demand proctoring Yes Yes Yes No
Proctoring feedback Not available Instructors may review recorded video Instructors may review recorded video  
Can proctor a paper exam Not available Not available Available Available
Prevents students from accessing other tabs/browsers/programs Available; can also add a site to an approved list Available Not Available Not Available
Online calculator Available (basic or scientific) Available (basic or scientific) Not available Not Available
Online scratch paper Not available Not available Not available Whiteboard Available
Video monitoring Not available Available Available Available
Record student’s desktop screen Not available Not available Available If screen share used
Clear cache when exiting exam Not available Not available Not available Not Available
Disable copy and paste Not available Not available Not available Not Available
Restrict student to one screen Available Available Will record all screens presented during recording Not Available
Foreign language characters Some available; keyboard language can be changed Some available; keyboard language can be changed  
Audio monitoring Not available Available Available Available
Room scan Not available Student is prompted to perform a scan at the beginning of the exam Available Available
 Key Features
  • Assessments are displayed full-screen and cannot be minimized.
  • Prevents access to other applications including messaging, screen-sharing, virtual machines, and network monitoring applications.
  • Copying and pasting anything to or from an assessment is prevented.
  • An assessment cannot be exited until the student submits it for grading.
  • Start exam immediately.
  • Recorded ID check.
  • Student exam sessions are recorded via webcam and available to instructors for review.
  • Suspicious behaviors flagged and ranked.
  • Facial detection check can prevent exam from starting or prompt students to stay in frame.


YuJa’s exam proctoring feature ensures the security of student exams taken from remote locations.


Proctor Recorder also ensures that the recording is only securely allocated to a centralized instructor folder, which will avoid distribution of the exam recording by the student.

  
 Reports and Analytics No Yes No Yes

 

 

Assistive Technology Compatibility (as of Spring 2021)
Assistive Technology Respondus Lockdown Browser Respondus Monitor YuJa Zoom
Read and Write Not yet Not Yet Undetermined Undetermined
JAWS Yes Partially Yes
NVDA Yes Partially Yes
VoiceOver Yes, according to website Yes, according to website Yes
Narrator Yes, according to website Yes, according to website Undetermined
ChromeVox No No Yes
Dragon Naturally Speaking Partially, according to website Partially, according to website Undetermined
Windows Speech Recognition Partially Partially Undetermined
Dictate Undetermined Undetermined Undetermined